3D

Superposition, standing waves and resonance

The principle of superposition, constructive and destructive interference, how two waves travelling in opposite directions make a standing wave with nodes and antinodes, and resonance in mechanical systems, including the effect of damping.

In June 2000 the Millennium Footbridge across the Thames opened, and on its first day began to sway sideways so badly that people had to grab the rails. The bridge's natural sideways frequency, about 1 Hz, was close to the frequency of people's sideways sway as they walked. As it moved, people fell into step with it and pushed it further. It closed after two days and was fitted with dampers. Engineers now check every footbridge for exactly this kind of resonance.

The principle of superposition

When two or more waves pass through the same point at the same time, the resulting displacement is the sum of the displacements each wave would cause on its own:

$y_{\text{total}} = y_1 + y_2$

Displacements are signed, so a crest (positive) and a trough (negative) partly or completely cancel. After overlapping, each wave carries on unchanged, as if the other had never been there. Waves pass through each other; they do not bounce off each other.

Two pulses meeting. When the displacements are on the same side they add; when they are on opposite sides they cancel.
  • Constructive interference: waves meet in phase (crest on crest), so the amplitudes add and the result is larger.
  • Destructive interference: waves meet out of phase (crest on trough), so the result is smaller. Equal amplitudes cancel completely, for that instant.

Destructive interference does not destroy energy. At the moment two equal and opposite pulses cancel, the string is flat but every part of it is moving, so the energy is all kinetic for that instant. Noise-cancelling headphones use the idea: a microphone picks up incoming noise and the speaker plays the inverted wave so the two superpose to nearly zero at your ear.

Worked example: adding displacements

Pulse A has a maximum displacement of +3.0 cm and pulse B a maximum of −1.0 cm. They meet with their peaks at the same point. Find the displacement there at that instant, and the maximum displacement afterwards.

$y = (+3.0) + (-1.0) = +2.0$ cm.
overlap
Each pulse carries on unchanged: A still has +3.0 cm and B still has −1.0 cm.
afterwards

Standing waves

A wave that travels along, carrying energy from place to place, is a progressive (travelling) wave. If two identical waves travel in opposite directions through the same medium, usually a wave and its reflection, their superposition is a standing wave: a pattern that oscillates in place but does not travel.

A standing wave on a string. Nodes never move; antinodes have the largest oscillation.
  • Nodes are points that never move, because the two waves always cancel there.
  • Antinodes are points of maximum oscillation, halfway between nodes, with an amplitude of twice that of each travelling wave.
  • Neighbouring nodes (or antinodes) are $\lambda/2$ apart, where $\lambda$ is the wavelength of the travelling waves.
  • All points between two neighbouring nodes move in phase; points in the next section move in antiphase.
Progressive waveStanding wave
Energytransferred along the wavestored in the pattern; no net transfer
Amplitudesame for every particlezero at nodes, greatest at antinodes
Phasechanges steadily along the waveall points between two nodes in phase
Patternmoves at speed $v$stays in place

A string fixed at both ends can only hold standing waves that have a node at each end, so only certain wavelengths "fit". Those allowed patterns are the harmonics that give musical instruments their notes; page 3F works through them.

Worked example: measuring a standing wave

A string vibrated at 120 Hz shows a standing wave with nodes 25 cm apart. Find the wavelength and the speed of the travelling waves that make it.

Node to node is $\lambda/2$, so $\lambda = 2 \times 0.25 = 0.50$ m.
wavelength
$v = f\lambda = 120 \times 0.50 = 60\ \text{m s}^{-1}$.
speed

Resonance in mechanical systems

Pull a mass on a spring down and let go: it oscillates at its own natural frequency $f_0$, set by the system (the mass and the stiffness of the spring), not by how far you pulled it. Every object that can vibrate has one or more natural frequencies.

Now drive the system with a periodic force at a driving frequency $f_d$. After a short time it settles into oscillating at $f_d$. How big the oscillation is depends on how close $f_d$ is to $f_0$:

  • Far from $f_0$, the pushes are often against the motion, so little energy is transferred and the amplitude stays small.
  • When $f_d = f_0$, every push is in step with the motion, so energy is transferred to the system on every cycle and the amplitude grows until the energy lost each cycle (to friction, air resistance and so on) equals the energy put in. This is resonance: the largest amplitude occurs when the driving frequency matches the natural frequency.
Amplitude against driving frequency. Damping lowers and widens the resonance peak.

Damping is anything that removes energy from the oscillation. Heavier damping gives a lower, broader peak; very light damping gives a tall, sharp one. Within the system, energy is continually transformed between kinetic energy and potential energy (elastic or gravitational), and damping transforms some into thermal energy each cycle.

Resonance is useful in a swing pushed in time, the body of a guitar, the quartz crystal that keeps time in a watch, and MRI scanners. It is dangerous in bridges, buildings in earthquakes, and car parts that rattle at particular engine speeds. Engineers either shift the natural frequency away from likely driving frequencies or add damping, such as the tuned mass dampers in tall buildings.

Worked example: a resonance problem

A car's dashboard panel rattles loudly at an engine speed of 2700 rpm and is quiet at other speeds. (a) Find the natural frequency of the panel. (b) Suggest two ways to stop the rattle.

$f = \dfrac{2700}{60} = 45$ Hz, assuming the engine drives the panel once per revolution.
frequency
Add damping (a foam pad or rubber mount) to remove energy each cycle, or change the natural frequency by adding a clip or mass so it no longer matches 45 Hz.
fixes
InteractiveSuperposition and resonance
Try this
  • In Two pulses mode with both amplitudes at 1.0, wait for the pulses to meet: the middle of the string reaches 2.00. Set pulse B to −1.0: the readout falls to 0.00 at the meeting moment.
  • Turn on Show each pulse and check that the yellow curve is always the sum of the dashed ones. Do the pulses change after they pass?
  • In Standing wave mode, find the points marked N. Do they ever move? Check that they are 20 cm apart when λ = 40 cm.
  • In Resonance mode with light damping, set 1.00 Hz: the steady amplitude is 12.0 cm. At 0.50 Hz it is only 0.8 cm. Switch to heavy damping at 1.00 Hz: 2.4 cm.
Four black-and-white film frames of a suspension bridge deck twisting
Frames from film of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge twisting in November 1940, shortly before it collapsed. The steady wind set up large self-sustaining twisting oscillations; engineers today describe this as aeroelastic flutter rather than simple resonance, but it is why bridges are now tested for their natural frequencies.Photo: Barney Elliott, CC0

Test yourself

  1. Two pulses of amplitude 4 cm and −4 cm on a rope meet so that their peaks coincide. At that instant

  2. A standing wave has adjacent antinodes 15 cm apart and a frequency of 200 Hz. The speed of the travelling waves is

  3. Which statement correctly distinguishes a standing wave from a progressive wave?

  4. A child on a swing with a natural frequency of 0.40 Hz is pushed once every 2.5 s. Increasing friction at the swing's pivot would

Label the resonance graph.

driving frequencyamplitude of the oscillationnatural frequency f₀resonance: largest amplitudemore damping: lower, wider peak

Progressive or standing?

When waves overlap, the total displacement is the of the individual displacements. Points on a standing wave that never move are , and neighbouring ones are a wavelength apart. A driven system has its largest amplitude when the driving frequency equals its frequency. Adding makes the resonance peak lower and broader.

6 marks

A mass hanging on a spring has a natural frequency of 2.0 Hz. It is attached to a vibrator whose frequency is slowly increased from 0.5 Hz to 4.0 Hz. (a) Describe how the amplitude of the mass changes, and sketch the expected graph. (b) Analyse the transfer and transformation of energy in the system at resonance. (c) Predict the effect of attaching a large card to the mass.