NESA key word · Judge and argue

ProposeWhat it means in HSC questions, with worked answers

Propose asks you to put forward an idea, method or argument for someone to consider or act on. A strong proposal is specific and says why it would work.

At a glance

In plain EnglishPut forward a point of view, idea, argument or suggestion for others to consider or act on.

NESA’s meaningNESA’s glossary describes propose as putting forward a point of view, idea, argument or suggestion for consideration or action. Read NESA’s glossary

Recall and name Describe and summarise Explain and relate Analyse and reason Judge and argue Do and apply

Weigh it up and commit to a judgement or position you can support.

What markers look for

  • A specific, practical suggestion.
  • Enough detail to act on it.
  • The reason it would work or what it would achieve.

How to answer a ‘propose’ question

  1. Make the suggestionBe specific: what exactly would you do?
  2. Add the key detailsEquipment, conditions, what you’d measure or observe.
  3. Say why it worksLink it to a principle or to the problem it solves.

Worked examples: weak vs strong

Each strong answer is highlighted to show what earns the marks. Switch the labels on to see why.

Chemistry Year 12 Chemistry · Organic chemistry 3 marks

Propose a chemical test to distinguish between hexane and hex-1-ene.

Weak answer

Smell them, because they smell different.

Unsafe and not a chemical test.

Strong answer

Add a few drops of bromine water to a sample of each, in the dark or away from UV light, and shake. Hex-1-ene decolourises the orange-brown bromine water quickly, while hexane does not (it stays orange-brown). Hex-1-ene’s C=C double bond reacts with bromine in an addition reaction. Hexane is saturated and only reacts by substitution in UV light, so without UV there is no visible change.

A specific test, expected observations, and the chemistry that makes it work.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Chemistry: Organic chemistry notes
Physics Year 11 Physics · Practical skills 2 marks

A student times one swing of a pendulum with a stopwatch. Propose a change to improve the reliability of the measurement.

Weak answer

Be more careful when using the stopwatch.

Too vague to act on.

Strong answer

Time 10 complete oscillations and divide by 10, and repeat this 3 to 5 times to find an average. This spreads the reaction-time error over many swings and averages out random errors, so repeated results agree more closely.

A specific change and why it improves reliability.

Revise the topic: Year 11 resources

Common mistakes

Vague ideas: ‘do it more carefully’.

Fix: Name the exact change.

No reason given.

Fix: Add ‘This would… because…’.

Sentence starters

Tap one to copy it.

‘Propose’ in different subjects

Science
Propose a test, an improvement to a method, or a model to explain data.
English
Propose an interpretation or a thesis.

Often confused with

Quick check

1. Which is a strong proposal?

Questions about ‘propose’

Do I need to justify my proposal?

A reason is expected. A proposal with no reason reads as a guess.