NESA key word · Judge and argue

AssessWhat it means in HSC questions, with worked answers

Assess asks for a judgement. You weigh up how significant, effective, accurate or large something is, then say so clearly and back it up.

At a glance

In plain EnglishMake a judgement about the value, quality, outcomes, results or size of something.

NESA’s meaningNESA’s glossary describes assess as making a judgement of value, quality, outcomes, results or size. Read NESA’s glossary

Recall and name Describe and summarise Explain and relate Analyse and reason Judge and argue Do and apply

Weigh it up and commit to a judgement or position you can support.

What markers look for

  • An explicit judgement (highly / moderately / not significant, accurate, effective).
  • Evidence or data supporting it, ideally on more than one side.
  • The judgement links back to the exact words of the question.
  • Specific detail, not generalities.

How to answer a ‘assess’ question

  1. Decide your judgementBefore writing, decide how big, good or significant it is.
  2. Lead with itYour first sentence should state the judgement.
  3. Support itGive evidence for it, and acknowledge anything that limits it.
  4. Close the loopEnd by restating the judgement in the question’s own words.

Worked examples: weak vs strong

Each strong answer is highlighted to show what earns the marks. Switch the labels on to see why.

Physics Year 12 Physics · The nature of light 5 marks

Assess the contribution of Einstein’s explanation of the photoelectric effect to our understanding of light.

Weak answer

Einstein explained the photoelectric effect using photons, which was very important. He won a Nobel Prize.

A judgement (‘very important’) but almost no physics to support it.

Strong answer

Einstein’s explanation was a major turning point, because it showed light must have particle properties. The wave model predicted that brighter light would give electrons more energy and that any frequency would work given enough time. Experiments instead showed a threshold frequency, instant emission, and a maximum kinetic energy that depended on frequency, not intensity. Einstein proposed that light comes in quanta of energy E = hf, so K_max = hf − φ. This explained every observation, and Millikan’s experiments confirmed the linear relationship. It led to the idea of wave–particle duality, since interference still requires waves. Its contribution was therefore highly significant.

Judgement first and last, with the failure of the wave model and the success of E = hf as evidence.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Physics: The nature of light notes
Chemistry Year 11 Chemistry · Drivers of reactions 4 marks

A student burns ethanol in a spirit burner under a copper can of water. Three trials give enthalpies of combustion of −1020, −985 and −1040 kJ/mol. The accepted value is −1367 kJ/mol. Assess the accuracy and reliability of these results.

Weak answer

The results are not accurate because they are different from the real value.

Addresses accuracy only, gives no figures and no cause.

Strong answer

The results are reliable: the three trials agree within about ±3% of their mean of −1015 kJ/mol. However, they are not accurate, being about 26% smaller in magnitude than the accepted value. This consistent shortfall points to a systematic error: heat is lost to the air and the can, combustion is incomplete (soot forms), and some ethanol may evaporate rather than burn. So the method is reliable but has low accuracy.

Separate judgements for reliability and accuracy, each backed by the data, plus the reason for the error.

Revise the topic: Year 11 Chemistry: Drivers of reactions notes
Maths Year 12 Maths Standard 2 · Bivariate data 3 marks

For hours studied and exam mark, a class finds Pearson’s correlation coefficient r = 0.31. Assess whether the least-squares regression line should be used to predict a student’s mark.

Weak answer

r is positive, so studying more gives a higher mark and the line can be used.

Ignores the strength of r and assumes causation.

Strong answer

r = 0.31 shows a weak positive linear association. Points are widely scattered around the line, so predictions would have large errors, especially outside the range of the data (extrapolation). Correlation also doesn’t show that extra study causes higher marks. So the line is not a reliable tool for predicting an individual student’s mark.

Interprets r, explains its effect on prediction, and ends with a clear judgement.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Maths Standard notes

Common mistakes

Explaining the topic but never judging it.

Fix: Use judgement words: ‘significant’, ‘limited’, ‘highly accurate’.

A judgement with no evidence.

Fix: Each claim needs a fact, figure or example.

Sitting on the fence.

Fix: Qualify if needed, but commit: ‘largely effective, except…’.

Sentence starters

Tap one to copy it.

‘Assess’ in different subjects

Science
Judge the significance of a discovery, the accuracy or reliability of results, or the effectiveness of a method.
Maths
Judge the strength of a relationship, the suitability of a model, or whether a prediction can be trusted.
English
Judge how effectively a text or technique achieves something.

Often confused with

Quick check

1. Where does the judgement belong in an assess answer?
2. Results are close together but far from the accepted value. They are…

Questions about ‘assess’

Is assess the same as ‘to what extent’?

‘To what extent’ isn’t in NESA’s glossary, but it calls for the same thing: a judgement about degree, supported by evidence.

Can my judgement be ‘partly’?

Yes. A qualified judgement (‘largely effective, except at high temperatures’) is often stronger than an absolute one, as long as it is clear.