NESA key word · Judge and argue

Critically analyse / critically evaluateWhat it means in HSC questions, with worked answers

Adding ‘critically’ raises the bar. You still analyse or evaluate, but you also question the evidence itself: how strong it is, what it leaves out, and whether the claim really holds.

At a glance

In plain EnglishAnalyse or evaluate with extra depth: interpret and reason through a range of evidence, and make judgements that are accurate, logical and reflective.

NESA’s meaningNESA’s glossary treats these as one entry. Critically analyse adds interpretation and reasoning to assess a range of evidence and make judgements based on detailed analysis. Critically evaluate adds a degree of accuracy, depth, knowledge, logic, reflection and quality to evaluating. Read NESA’s glossary

Recall and name Describe and summarise Explain and relate Analyse and reason Judge and argue Do and apply

Weigh it up and commit to a judgement or position you can support.

What markers look for

  • A full analysis or evaluation first: parts, relationships, criteria.
  • The evidence itself is questioned: strengths, limits, assumptions.
  • Other views or counter-evidence acknowledged.
  • A reasoned, qualified judgement at the end.

How to answer a ‘critically analyse / evaluate’ question

  1. Restate the claim preciselyWhat exactly is being claimed, and under what conditions?
  2. Lay out the evidence for itAnalyse it properly, with data and equations where they help.
  3. Test that evidenceWhat does it assume or ignore? Where does it break down?
  4. JudgeGive a verdict that reflects both: ‘true in principle, but not in practice, because…’.

Worked examples: weak vs strong

Each strong answer is highlighted to show what earns the marks. Switch the labels on to see why.

Chemistry Year 12 Chemistry · Organic chemistry 6 marks

Critically analyse the claim that ethanol is a carbon-neutral fuel.

Weak answer

Ethanol is carbon neutral because plants absorb CO₂ when they grow. This makes it better than petrol.

States one side of the argument, with no chemistry and no critique.

Strong answer

The claim rests on the carbon cycle of the fuel itself. Photosynthesis absorbs 6 CO₂ for each glucose (6CO₂ + 6H₂O → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6O₂). Fermentation releases 2 CO₂ (C₆H₁₂O₆ → 2C₂H₅OH + 2CO₂), and burning the two ethanol molecules releases 4 more (C₂H₅OH + 3O₂ → 2CO₂ + 3H₂O, twice). The equations balance: 6 absorbed, 6 released. However, this only counts the chemistry of the fuel. Growing, fertilising and harvesting the crop, distilling the ethanol and transporting it all use energy, mostly from fossil fuels. Clearing land for crops can also release stored carbon. Ethanol also releases less energy per gram than petrol (about 30 kJ/g versus about 48 kJ/g), so more is burned for the same distance. So ethanol is carbon neutral in principle, according to the equations, but not in practice. It can still have lower net emissions than petrol when renewable energy powers its production.

Analyses the equations, challenges what they leave out, and gives a qualified judgement.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Chemistry: Organic chemistry notes
Physics Year 12 Physics · From the universe to the atom 6 marks

Critically evaluate the evidence that led scientists to accept the Big Bang theory over the steady state theory.

Weak answer

Hubble found that galaxies are moving away, so the universe started with a Big Bang.

Hubble’s observations alone can’t separate the two theories, and there is no judgement on the evidence.

Strong answer

In 1929 Hubble showed that galaxies’ redshifts increase with distance, so the universe is expanding. This was not decisive: the steady state theory also accepted expansion, adding new matter to keep the density constant. The cosmic microwave background, found by Penzias and Wilson in 1965, matched the Big Bang’s prediction of leftover radiation from a hot early universe, now cooled to about 2.7 K. The steady state theory had no natural explanation for it. The measured abundances of light elements (about 75% hydrogen and 25% helium by mass) also match Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Taken together, the evidence strongly favours the Big Bang, with the CMB as the deciding piece. Open questions, such as the nature of dark energy, refine the model rather than overturn it.

Weighs each piece of evidence by how well it separates the two theories, then judges.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Physics: From the universe to the atom notes

Common mistakes

Writing a normal analyse answer.

Fix: ‘Critically’ needs at least one paragraph that challenges the evidence.

Criticising without evidence.

Fix: Each limitation needs a specific reason or example.

No final judgement.

Fix: Finish with a qualified verdict on the claim.

Sentence starters

Tap one to copy it.

‘Critically analyse / evaluate’ in different subjects

Science
Test a claim, model or conclusion against evidence and its limitations.
English
Judge an interpretation or the effectiveness of a text, while weighing alternative readings.

Often confused with

Quick check

1. Which sentence makes an answer ‘critical’?

Questions about ‘critically analyse / evaluate’

How long should a critically analyse answer be?

These questions are usually worth 6 to 9 marks in science, and more in extended responses. Plan for an introduction to the claim, two or three body paragraphs and a judgement.

What makes an answer ‘critical’?

Questioning the evidence: its assumptions, limitations, reliability and what it fails to explain. Criticism alone isn’t enough; it must lead to a judgement.