DiscussWhat it means in HSC questions, with worked answers
Discuss asks you to raise the issues around a topic and give points for and/or against. Students often lose marks by writing only one side, or by turning it into a list with no evidence behind each point.
At a glance
In plain EnglishIdentify the issues and give points for and/or against.
NESA’s meaningNESA’s glossary describes discuss as identifying issues and providing points for and/or against. Read NESA’s glossary
Recall and nameDescribe and summariseExplain and relateAnalyse and reasonJudge and argueDo and apply
Weigh it up and commit to a judgement or position you can support.
What markers look for
The main issues are identified, not just one.
Points on more than one side (advantages and disadvantages, for and against).
Each point is backed by a reason or evidence, not just stated.
In longer answers, a short conclusion that weighs the points up.
How to answer a ‘discuss’ question
Name the issueOpen with one sentence that says what is being weighed up.
Points forGive your strongest points in favour, each with a reason or piece of evidence.
Points againstDo the same for the other side. Aim for balance unless the evidence clearly isn’t balanced.
Weigh it upFor 5 marks or more, finish with a sentence on which side is stronger, or under what conditions.
Worked examples: weak vs strong
Each strong answer is highlighted to show what earns the marks. Switch the labels on to see why.
ChemistryYear 12 Chemistry · Organic chemistry4 marks
Discuss the use of addition polymers such as polyethylene for food packaging.
Weak answer
Polyethylene is cheap and light, but it is bad for the environment.
Both sides appear, but no reasons, no chemistry and no weighing up. About 1 to 2 marks.
Strong answer
Polyethylene is widely used for food packaging, which raises the issue of convenience against environmental cost. In its favour, its long saturated carbon chains make it chemically unreactive, so it won’t react with food, and its non-polar chains repel water, keeping food dry. It is also light, cheap to make from ethylene and easy to mould into films and containers. However, the same stable C–C and C–H bonds mean it isn’t biodegradable, so discarded packaging persists for decades and breaks into microplastics. It is made from crude oil, a non-renewable resource, and burning it releases CO₂. Its benefits are greatest where it is collected and recycled; without that, the environmental costs are hard to justify.
Points on both sides, each tied to the polymer’s structure, and a conclusion that weighs them under conditions.
Discuss the use of geostationary satellites compared with low Earth orbit satellites for communication.
Weak answer
Geostationary satellites stay in the same place, so they are better. Low Earth orbit satellites move.
One point each and a one-sided verdict with no physics behind it.
Strong answer
A geostationary satellite orbits at about 36 000 km with a 24-hour period, so it stays above one point on the equator and ground dishes can stay fixed. Three can cover most of the planet. However, the round trip to that altitude adds a delay of about a quarter of a second, the signal is weaker, and coverage near the poles is poor. Low Earth orbit satellites, a few hundred kilometres up, have much shorter delays and need less launch energy. But each one crosses the sky in minutes, so a large constellation and tracking or hand-over between satellites are needed. Geostationary orbits suit broadcasting to fixed dishes, while low orbits suit fast two-way data such as internet.
Balanced points with physical reasons and a conclusion that matches each orbit to a use.
Discuss the use of nuclear power to generate electricity.
Weak answer
Nuclear power is dangerous because of accidents like Chernobyl, so it should not be used.
One side only, and an opinion in place of a discussion.
Strong answer
Nuclear power stations release almost no carbon dioxide while operating, which helps reduce greenhouse emissions. They also produce large amounts of electricity reliably, day and night, regardless of weather. On the other hand, the spent fuel stays radioactive for thousands of years and must be stored securely. Plants are expensive and slow to build, and accidents, though rare, can contaminate large areas. Whether the benefits outweigh the risks depends on a country’s other low-emission options and its ability to manage waste safely.
Two points on each side and a conditional conclusion.
Do I have to give a conclusion in a discuss question?
NESA’s meaning is points for and/or against, so a verdict isn’t strictly required. In answers worth 5 or more marks, a short concluding judgement usually strengthens the response.
Does discuss always need both sides?
‘For and/or against’ allows one side, but most HSC marking guidelines reward a balanced response. Cover both unless the question clearly points one way.