NESA key word · Judge and argue

JustifyWhat it means in HSC questions, with worked answers

Justify gives you the conclusion (or asks you to choose one) and wants the evidence and reasoning that make it hold. It is about proof, not opinion.

At a glance

In plain EnglishSupport an argument or conclusion.

NESA’s meaningNESA’s glossary describes justify as supporting an argument or conclusion. Read NESA’s glossary

Recall and name Describe and summarise Explain and relate Analyse and reason Judge and argue Do and apply

Weigh it up and commit to a judgement or position you can support.

What markers look for

  • The position or answer is stated clearly.
  • Specific evidence: data, a law, a test result or a calculation.
  • Reasoning that connects the evidence to the conclusion.
  • In Maths, a test or check that proves the claim.

How to answer a ‘justify’ question

  1. State the positionSay what you are justifying.
  2. Give the evidenceThe fact, law, result or calculation it rests on.
  3. Connect themShow why that evidence leads to the conclusion.

Worked examples: weak vs strong

Each strong answer is highlighted to show what earns the marks. Switch the labels on to see why.

Chemistry Year 11 Chemistry · Reactive chemistry 3 marks

A solution contains either barium nitrate or magnesium nitrate. Justify the use of dilute sulfuric acid to identify it.

Weak answer

Sulfuric acid reacts with barium, so it is a good test.

Doesn’t say what you would see, or why magnesium behaves differently.

Strong answer

Dilute sulfuric acid can distinguish the two because their sulfates differ in solubility. Barium sulfate is insoluble, so with barium nitrate a white precipitate forms: Ba²⁺(aq) + SO₄²⁻(aq) → BaSO₄(s). Magnesium sulfate is soluble, so no precipitate forms. The test therefore gives a clear, visible difference between the two possibilities.

Position, solubility evidence with an equation, and why it settles the question.

Revise the topic: Year 11 Chemistry: Reactive chemistry notes
Physics Year 12 Physics · Electromagnetism 3 marks

Justify why a transformer must be supplied with alternating current rather than direct current.

Weak answer

Transformers only work with AC.

Restates the claim without any physics.

Strong answer

A transformer works by electromagnetic induction: by Faraday’s law, an emf is induced in the secondary coil only when the magnetic flux through it changes. An alternating current in the primary produces a continuously changing flux in the iron core, so an emf is continuously induced in the secondary. A steady DC produces a constant flux, so no emf is induced except briefly when it is switched on or off. AC is therefore required.

The law, how AC satisfies it, and why DC doesn’t.

Revise the topic: Year 12 Physics: Electromagnetism notes
Maths Year 11 Maths Advanced · Differentiation 2 marks

Justify that (1, 2) is a maximum turning point of y = −x² + 2x + 1.

Weak answer

Because the parabola is concave down.

Partly right, but doesn’t show the point is stationary or lies on the curve.

Strong answer

dy/dx = −2x + 2 = 0 when x = 1, and y = −1 + 2 + 1 = 2, so (1, 2) is a stationary point. d²y/dx² = −2 < 0, so the curve is concave down there, which makes (1, 2) a maximum turning point.

Shows the point is stationary and proves its nature.

Revise the topic: Year 11 Maths Advanced: Differentiation notes

Common mistakes

Restating the conclusion more strongly.

Fix: ‘It is definitely correct’ isn’t a justification. Evidence is.

Evidence with no link to the claim.

Fix: Add a ‘which shows that…’ sentence.

Sentence starters

Tap one to copy it.

‘Justify’ in different subjects

Science
Back a choice of method, test, indicator or conclusion with chemistry or physics principles.
Maths
Prove a claim: use a test (second derivative, discriminant) or a calculation.
English
Support an interpretation with textual evidence.

Often confused with

Quick check

1. Which is a justification?

Questions about ‘justify’

Is justify the same as ‘show that’?

Not officially, but they are close in Maths: both want working that proves a given result.

Can I justify with an opinion?

No. Justification needs evidence: data, a law, a test or textual proof.